Online Bill Pay

Pay My Bill

At Maguire Insurance Agency, we make managing your insurance as simple as possible. Whether you are at home in Ithaca, Syracuse, or anywhere across New York State, you can access your carrier’s billing portal or pay by phone 24/7.

Need help with a billing question? Contact our local agents directly at (607) 261-1301.

Phone Numbers:

Payments can be made through the Allstate Mobile App or by calling 1‑800‑901‑1732.

Dryden Mutual

Call 800‑694‑8271 or create an online account to pay.

Finger Lakes Insurance Company

Payments can be made by calling 607‑387‑6800 or online.


Foremost Insurance Group

Payments can be made by calling 1‑800‑532‑4221. Or online.

Nationwide Insurance

Payments can be made by calling 1‑866‑665‑4992 Or online.

Kemper Insurance Company

Call 1‑800‑933‑8788 or set up an account to pay online.


Leatherstocking Insurance Company

Billing can be reached at 607-547-2007. Or a one-time payment can be made online.

Mercury Insurance

Payments can be made by calling 1‑800-503-3724 Or online.

National General Insurance

Call 1‑877-468-3466 or pay online.


NYCM Insurance Company

Payments can be made by calling 1-800-234-6926. Or online.

Payments can be made through the Progressive Mobile App, by calling 1‑800-503-3724 Or online.

Safeco Insurance

Payments can be made by calling 1‑888-723-3260 or pay online.


Main Street America Insurance

One-time payments available online.

Travelers Insurance

Payments can be made through the Travelers app, online, or by calling 1‑800-842-5075

Utica National Insurance Group

Payments can be made by calling 1‑800-598-8422 or pay online.


Security Mutual Group Insurance

One-time payments available online.

Preferred Mutual Insurance Group

Payments can be made online, or by calling 1‑800‑333‑7642

Hagerty Insurance Group

Payments can be made by calling 1‑877‑922‑9701 or pay online.


Payments can be made by calling 716‑856‑8057.

Frequently Asked Questions

Everything you need to know about billing and payments.

Q: Can I pay my bill at a Maguire dealership?

A: While we are closely partnered with Maguire dealerships across NY, insurance premiums must be paid directly to your insurance carrier to ensure immediate coverage updates.


Q: What information do I need to pay my bill?

A: You will typically need your policy number and your zip code. Most carriers also allow you to pay using your account number found on your most recent billing statement.


Q: Who do I call if my policy has lapsed?

A: If you missed a payment and your policy is in "lapsed" status, please call our Trumansburg office immediately at (607) 261-1301 so we can assist with reinstatement.


Contact Us

Main 607-261-1301
318 Elmira Rd
Ithaca, NY 14850
Maguire Insurance 42.4275565, -76.5128283.