Flexible policies that grow with your business!

Business Insurance Solutions, Not Headaches.

Every business is different—and so are its risks. At Maguire Insurance Agency, we help New York businesses secure customized coverage by comparing policies from 400+ insurance carriers. From small businesses to growing enterprises, our experienced agents design protection plans that minimize liability exposure and safeguard revenue, employees, and assets. With our streamlined Quick Quote process, business owners can upload current policy documents securely, allowing us to analyze coverage and prepare recommendations before our first strategy meeting.

Comprehensive protection for your business.

We help you build commercial insurance packages that can include: 

• General Liability Insurance
• Commercial Property Insurance
• Business Owner’s Policies (BOP)
• Commercial Auto Insurance
• Workers’ Compensation
• Professional Liability (E&O)
• Cyber Liability Insurance
• Employment Practices Liability
• Umbrella & Excess Liability Coverage

Our goal is to eliminate coverage gaps that could expose your business to costly litigation or operational disruption.

Industry-specific coverage options

Because we work with hundreds of carriers, we can place specialized policies for:

• Contractors
• Retail Businesses
• Restaurants
• Professional Offices
• Manufacturers
• Nonprofits
• Real Estate Investors

We match your business with carriers experienced in your industry.

risk management & annual reviews

As your business grows, your risk profile changes. We conduct annual business insurance reviews to ensure coverage reflects:

• Revenue growth
• Equipment purchases
• Fleet expansion
• Workforce changes
• Regulatory updates

Proactive reviews help prevent underinsurance and compliance issues.

Local Expertise. Statewide Reach.

With offices throughout New York State, including Ithaca, Trumansburg, and Syracuse, our agents understand local regulations and business environments. Unlike national call centers, we provide responsive, relationship-based service when you need it most.