Employee Benefits

Benefits packages that show employees they matter.

Attracting and retaining great employees starts with competitive benefits.

Offering strong employee benefits isn’t just a perk—it’s a strategic advantage. Maguire Insurance Agency works with 400+ carriers and benefits providers to help New York businesses design cost-effective, competitive benefits packages.

Our experienced team simplifies the complex world of health insurance and employee benefits, ensuring compliance while helping employers control long-term costs.

benefits solutions designed around your team.

We assist employers with:

• Group Health Insurance
• Dental & Vision Plans
• Group Life Insurance
• Disability Insurance
• Supplemental & Voluntary Benefits
• COBRA Administration Support
• HR & Compliance Guidance

Our carrier relationships allow us to compare plan structures, networks, and pricing to build packages aligned with your company’s budget and culture.

Smarter Shopping with Quick quote

The quoting process for group benefits can be time-consuming. Our secure document upload system, Quick Quote, streamlines underwriting preparation, allowing us to analyze your current plan structure before presenting alternative solutions. 

Our Quick Quote process:

• Reduces meeting time
• Improves quoting accuracy
• Speeds carrier comparisons
• Minimizes administrative frustration

Compliance & Annual Review

Healthcare regulations and workforce expectations evolve constantly. We provide annual benefits reviews to ensure your plans remain competitive, compliant, and aligned with employee needs.

Dedicated Local Support for employers

Benefits decisions impact your workforce and your bottom line. Our local agents provide hands-on support during renewals, enrollment periods, and employee questions—something online-only brokers simply can’t offer.

Phone Numbers:Ithaca Office Hours:
  • Mon - Fri8:00 AM - 5:00 PM
  • Sat - SunClosed
Trumansburg Office Hours:
  • Mon - Fri8:00 AM - 5:00 PM
  • Sat - SunClosed
Syracuse Office Hours:
  • Mon - Fri8:00 AM - 5:00 PM
  • Sat - SunClosed

Contact Us

Main 607-261-1301
318 Elmira Rd
Ithaca, NY 14850
Maguire Insurance 42.4275565, -76.5128283.