Personal

Coverage Designed Around Your Life

From life insurance to umbrella policies and recreational coverage, protecting your future requires more than a one-size-fits-all plan. At Maguire Insurance Agency, we compare coverage options from 400+ insurance carriers to tailor personal insurance policies that fit your lifestyle and long-term goals.

Our Quick Quote process allows you to securely upload current policies, enabling our licensed agents to review your coverage before your first conversation—saving time and eliminating frustration.

We proudly serve individuals and families throughout Ithaca, Trumansburg, Syracuse, and across New York State.

Coverage That Protects What Matters Most

We offer insight and guidance to keep you at ease…and protected. 

• Life Insurance (Term & Permanent)
• Personal Umbrella Policies
• Motorcycle Insurance
• Boat & Watercraft Insurance
• RV Insurance
• Recreational Vehicle Coverage
• High-Value Asset Protection

Speak with one of our knowledgeable agents today and get a free quote.

Bundle & Save

Bundling your personal insurance policies can significantly reduce premiums while simplifying your coverage management.

Popular combinations include:

• Auto + Umbrella
• Home + Umbrella
• Motorcycle + Auto
• Boat + Home
• Multi-Recreational Vehicle Policies

With access to hundreds of carriers, we identify companies offering the strongest multi-policy and loyalty discounts.

Umbrella Coverage-Extra Protection Beyond Standard Limits

Standard liability policies have limits. A personal umbrella policy adds an additional layer of financial protection if a major claim exceeds those limits.

Umbrella coverage is especially important for:

• Homeowners
• Families with teen drivers
• Property owners
• Individuals with significant assets
• Anyone concerned about lawsuit exposure

Our team ensures your liability protection matches your financial footprint.

Annual Coverage Reviews

Because Life Changes

Marriage, new children, career growth, property purchases, and asset increases all impact your insurance needs. We conduct annual personal insurance reviews to ensure your policies evolve alongside your life.

Local Advisors. Real Conversations.

Insurance decisions are personal. That’s why many clients prefer meeting with an agent in person. With convenient locations throughout New York State, our team is always available to review policies, explain options clearly, and support you when claims arise.